Frequently Asked Questions

Our most popular items are cookies cakes and s'more, chocolate chip M&M, and Circus White Chip cookies. 

At this time, we do not. However, some occasional exceptions can be made for those with a sensitivity or preference (not an allergy) to one of these ingredients if there's availability.  Only a few recipes have been perfected.

We cannot guarantee that our baked goods are peanut-free or tree nut-free as some items may contain traces of one or both or have ingredients made in a factory with tree-nuts/peanuts. However, we take precautions to prevent cross-contamination.

We take 1 order per month. We can only allot so much time for this product since they take longer to make. Our cut-outs are frosted with buttercream and/or rolled buttercream.  We only use royal icing for outlining. The frosting has a soft bite, but hardens enough to package. It taste delicious!

Cake is not a regular menu item, because cakes take a lot of my time. It's not my specialty, but on occasion I may make a cake or mini cake for the rare customer or vendor event. 

It is recommended to inquire about an order at least 1-2 weeks ahead of time.  For decorated sugar cookies and summer months, 1 month out is preferred.  However, please reach out to see what my availability is.  On average, 1-3 orders are only taken per week along side my day job.  

I accept cash or card. All orders must be paid in full 1 week prior to when you need your product. 

Being a small, home bakery, it is important that products are paid and picked up. Customized items are hard to resell if an item isn't picked up and left unpaid. Time and money need to be used wisely, especially when it comes to product cost and my baking time. You are always welcome to drop off cash 1 week before your order is due if cash is your preference. Large orders may require a down payment. 

I can only ship items that are secure within the state of Wisconsin.  For example, cookie cakes do not ship safely.  Customers will be charged a shipping fee.  

No. At this time Sweet Treats by Amy is a cottage food (home) bakery following WI Cottage Food Laws.

Once you've ordered, you will receive our address. It is vital that you pick-up your item within your window time frame.  If you are running late, we may not be able to accommodate.